the blog

notes from the field

11/09/2026

Do Small Businesses Still Need SEO? What AI Overviews Changed (and What They Didn’t).

The short story: Yes, fewer people are clicking through to websites, and AI Overviews are a big reason why. But for most small businesses, your best leads come from people searching for you by name, nearby customers searching for your service, and referrals. Get the basics right, keep them maintained, and you can stop sweating the rest until you actually need it.

A lot of my clients have been asking the same question lately: Why am I getting fewer website visits and fewer leads than I used to?

You’re not imagining it. But it’s probably less scary than it feels.

What changed: AI Overviews.

We don’t own Google. We can follow best practices to help our websites show up, but Google can change how search works whenever it wants, and it has.

Many searches now show an AI-generated summary at the top of the page, and that summary often answers the question before anyone clicks. The research backs this up. In a Pew Research Center analysis, people who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional search result in 8% of visits, compared with 15% of visits when no summary appeared. They clicked links inside the summary itself in just 1% of visits. (Google disputed the study’s methodology, for what it’s worth, but the trend matches what many site owners are seeing.)

The searches most affected are questions. Longer, question-style searches trigger AI summaries more often, while only 8% of one- or two-word searches produced one.

That’s the real shift. Someone who just wanted an answer used to land on your website, read your take and maybe discover your offers. Now they get their answer without meeting you.

The good news: AI is still recommending you.

When I search for problems my clients solve, AI tools are recommending them by name. I’ve seen it for a few clients so far: one with an online program, and two with in-person businesses.

That means the basic work we’ve been doing all along is working.

The catch: many searchers don’t want a program or an appointment. They just want an answer. Those are the clicks you’re losing, and they were rarely your best leads.

SEO isn’t the magic missing link.

Everyone asks me about SEO as if it’s the missing piece of their business. That’s why I created No Stress SEO. For the average business, it isn’t rocket science. Your website needs to clearly say what you do, in the places Google and AI tools look, so they can understand it and send the right people your way.

For some businesses, SEO is critical, especially if search is your main source of new clients. But before you stress about it, take an honest look at where your business actually comes from.

How people really decide to buy.

One of my clients kept coming back to SEO. Her business coach, a big name in her industry, talks about it constantly, and my client had invested heavily in that coach’s program.

So I tried to find the coach on Google. I searched every term I could think of. She never showed up.

My client didn’t find her through search either. She followed her on Instagram for years, heard about the program from friends, saw ads and joined launches that started with free content. That’s what led to a big-ticket decision.

And when that same client hired me? She didn’t search for a web designer in Collingwood. She heard about me from friends, got to know me in conversation and on Instagram, and when a project came up, she reached out. She’s been one of my biggest clients for years.

One story doesn’t prove search doesn’t matter. But it’s a good reminder to check how your own clients find you before assuming search is the problem.

Comparison makes it worse.

When we compare ourselves to big-name businesses with big search strategies, we can stop doing the small things that actually move the needle: referrals, relationships and follow-ups.

That’s why talking through your business with someone regularly matters. It’s easy to forget what’s actually working.

Know who’s searching for you.

Another client told me her website leads had dropped. So we dug into her data. How many of those leads ever converted? How many people found her through a vague search, and how many searched her name directly?

Most of her searches were for her. People already knew who they were looking for.

For most small businesses, the searches that matter fall into two groups:

People looking for you specifically:

  • Your name
  • Your business name
  • Your product or service name, alone or with your name

Nearby people looking for what you do:

  • Your main service plus your location (“chiropractor Collingwood,” “web designer Georgian Bay”)

That second group matters. These people don’t know you yet, but they’re ready to book. For clinics, studios and other local service businesses, they can be a major source of new clients.

The basics every small business needs.

1. A clearly optimized website.

Your website should say what you do, who you help and where, in your page titles, headings and content. That’s what No Stress SEO teaches, and if we built your website together, it’s already done.

2. A complete Google Business Profile.

This is the biggest piece for local businesses, and it’s free. Google says local results are based mainly on relevance, distance and prominence. You can’t change your distance from a searcher, but you can improve the other two: fill out your profile completely, pick the right categories and keep your hours and services current.

3. Reviews.

Google confirms that review count and review score factor into local search ranking, and more reviews and positive ratings can improve your local ranking. Make it easy for happy clients to leave one.

4. Consistent listings.

Google also judges prominence using information about your business from across the web, like links, articles and directories. Make sure your name, address and phone number match everywhere you’re listed.

5. A website that is current.

Google and AI tools want to know one thing: Is this a real business that will actually help people? A site that’s maintained, updated as your offers and hours change, and clearly connected to a real business sends that signal.

One myth worth dropping: the age of your domain on its own doesn’t help. Search Engine Journal’s verdict is that Google has said domain age is not a ranking factor. What helps is a site with a real track record of being useful.

These basics aren’t “set it and forget it,” but they’re not a full-time job either. Set them up properly, then check in a few times a year.

Next steps, once your basics are in place.

If your foundation is solid and you’re ready to do more, here’s where I’d look next:

  1. Check your data. Google Search Console shows what people searched to find you. Compare searches for your name with searches for your service. It tells you whether you have a visibility problem or a different problem.
  2. Build a review habit. Ask at the right moment, every time. A QR code on a thank-you card or receipt makes it easy.
  3. Create pages for your main services and locations. One clear page per core service, with your service area, helps both Google and AI tools match you to the right searches.
  4. Answer your clients’ real questions. Write about what clients actually ask you, from firsthand experience. That’s the kind of content AI tools are most likely to cite and that readers trust.
  5. Strengthen your referral sources. If other professionals send you clients, make it easy for them.

That last one deserves a story. For my second client, we discovered most of her leads come from referrals, often doctors sending patients her way. So we doubled down. Thank-you cards for referring practitioners, with one QR code for leaving a review and another linking to a page that explains exactly how she can help their patients.

Instead of waiting for people to maybe Google her, we’re reaching out in a way that’s kind, respectful and easy.

MEET THEM WHERE THEY ARE. ANSWER THEIR QUESTIONS, AND EVERYTHING ELSE WILL FALL INTO PLACE.

When SEO deserves a bigger investment.

SEO is worth a bigger investment if:

  • Most of your clients are strangers searching for a service
  • You don’t have a physical location, a referral network or an audience to draw from
  • You’ve already got social media, referrals and advertising working well

In my experience, most small businesses aren’t there yet. That’s okay.

You don’t need to stress about SEO.

If we built your website together, your website basics are covered. If your services have changed, we can revisit it or give it a refresh.

If you’ve never optimized your website, No Stress SEO will walk you through the basics.

And if you’re ready for the next steps, like setting up your Google Business Profile, building a review system, creating service pages or making it easier for referral partners to send people your way, let’s talk. That’s exactly the kind of thing we love to help with.

Remember: SEO puts you in front of people who are already searching. Everything else, the referrals, the relationships, the word of mouth, being in the right place at the right time, is how most small businesses grow. For the average small business, I’m not kidding, that’s enough.

more posts

wanna keep reading?

oh hi

k, but who tf is writing this?

Why it’s me, Lora. Thanks for asking. 

I started this company in 2017 and it was the best, most healing, funnest ride I’ve taken outside of being a mom – so I like to share what I’ve learned along the way.

This is a pic of me in my early creative endeavours, with the best man that ever lived, and unfortunately, ever died.

He was my model of entrepreneurship and he did it with bravery, integrity and NEVER subscribing to what everyone else was doing.

Finding my footing in the shadow of a legend was a big part of who I have become. So I guess you could say he’s writing this too.

Love you pops.

Free / Cheap Stuff
supports for small biz

Your homepage is the most commonly un-optimized page I see during website audits. This tool is designed to help you avoid the most common setbacks and get your homepage working for you.

I know. You put hours into your messaging. You proofread it 50 times. The ANXIETY you felt before you hit send? I’ve been there. I am certain your content is on point. But can I let you in on a little secret?

Your job isn’t done at crafting the perfect message.

Take your website from unfindable to a respectable position in Google Search, all on your own.

Join our email community to stay in the loop with deals, tips for diy-ing your design and some good old-fashioned cheerleading.

let's hang!
want to work together?

You have the vision. Let’s bring it to life. We build beautiful, function-forward websites, courses and digital foundations that have been transforming entrepreneurial dreams into real, working businesses since 2017.